Sunday, April 22, 2012

GMOs, Climate Change and Identity

What I found most interesting in doing this poster presentation and viewing the other poster presentations this past week was analyzing the idea of "identity" and it's place in all of these subjects.

My presentation focused on "climate change denial" and, as a "liberal" I think that climate change deniers are just stupid- or at least I did. Now I think they're just kind of willfully ignorant, but for an important purpose: by embracing a belief they associate themselves with a label which in turn gives them access to the community that label represents... and the security that then comes with that. That's why the "rhetoric" and "psychology" bit of my group's project was so interesting to me. Facts can say one thing... society and the people in it can say something entirely, radically different.

The other two presentations also dealt with identity to some extent: the "Just Say Know to GMOs" group without directly saying "this is about identity" presented facts (and cookies) that were meant to combat a growing group of people who are opposed to GMOs mainly because it's the "hip liberal" thing to do right now. Granted, there are many (many) reasons to avoid GMOs but one of them is not "because it's cool."

We all have seeing devices in which we view the world: companies that have a lot of money (the big conservative oil giants, Monsanto, tobacco companies) all put a lot of effort (see: $$$$$$$) into making sure that our seeing devices are really glasses that they control. On the other hand, there's a "hip" community that also tries to change the perspective of our seeing devices and although liberal organizations typically don't have as much money as their opposers (not saying they don't have a lot, just saying they don't have AS MUCH) they do have help from big players like Hollywood (every cool character ever is a liberal).
What I'm trying to say here is that we all have different views on the world and we're all subject to having those views swayed by people that have ulterior motives. We all have a human need to identify with groups, to associate ourselves with other human beings (or our existence is pretty pointless, hello nihilism). And this is how identity plays into almost anything we could imagine. I even find myself disagreeing with someone or something just because I think that the "group" that I "identify" with would probably also oppose said thing... even though I might not even know a lot about whatever I'm opposing. I'm not saying I walk around screaming about how unfair our capital bourgeois society is, but I'm saying that I catch myself, just like I'm sure a lot of other people do, denying or upholding something that I don't really know anything about- just so I can have an affirmed place in "my" "sub"-society.

I look forward to seeing the rest of the poster presentations and being able to poke around and see how "identity" influences the presentations, my (our) peers, and our society.

2 comments:

  1. I like what you said about how our friends and the group of people that we associate often guide our viewpoints. I know personally know that there are some issues I don't necessarily have an opinion on, but after being surrounded by people with one opinion, it makes me curious to see the viewpoints of the other side. I like how you brought up identity, because of course people want a sense of belonging to a certain group, but sometimes that identity intersects with particular viewpoint and heavily influences their opinions. These are the opinions that form when you don't really know anything about the topic, and like you said, we've all been there. In order to have a group identity, we form an opinion congruent with the rest of the group, even though we don't really know what we are talking about. I know I'm guilty there.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Shelby, you bring in such an important concept here, "identity". "Identity" plays a huge role in all of the topics that were presented last week as well as practically everything we have discussed in the class this semester. I have to agree with you when you say some people tend to sway towards what is "cool", not only that though people tend to sway towards what they are most exposed to and by what they are able to connect with through others around them. What a person is exposed to tends to be what they express as their belief and to them may seem inherent. I think we have done a good job in this class is finding that identity is not inherent and their are many factors that play in creating one's own identity. Your post was very insightful, thank you for bringing "identity" back into discussion!

    ReplyDelete